Sunday, 8 April 2012

Rohit Arya – Titanic glorifies poverty and demeans love



The film Titanic has always irritated me for the warped logic it proudly perpetuates. It is a dangerous movie, reinforcing people in beliefs they would be much better off jettisoning. It glorifies poverty consciousness, lack based systems and its attitude to love is deplorable. Naturally it was a huge success, finally dethroning that other sentimental monster The Sound of Music from its pinnacle as the highest box office success of all time. Oh yes, once you adjust for inflation, Jurassic Park and Gone with the Wind sink under “Doe- a deer, a female deer”. There is something terribly depressing about that. Even more ghastly is that the man who made the first two Terminator movies and Aliens turned out this schlock! Avatar has redeemed Cameron but Titanic remains a sin. Its re-release in 3D finally allows me to vent.


Let us get the positives out of the way. It is actually a good film. Technically it holds up really well and converting to only proves how well he and his team know their job. The second part is perhaps the greatest disaster movie ever made. Cameron’s obsessive eye for detail even went to the extent of drawing every sketch in Jack’s notebook. It was well observed that he was the only man in Hollywood, other than perhaps Spielberg who could have managed such a project. I remember reading an interview in a photography magazine with Cameron, he went on for almost six pages of small type on the lens and lighting and camera angles. The man is a monster for work , and merits all his triumphs but why in the name of God Almighty did he   perpetuate this horror upon us? In a well- deserved chastisement from Fate, his Oscar was followed by a divorce and a fallow period for 12 years before he came roaring back with Avatar. So he is forgiven, barely so.   But he really should not push such cynical buttons on people programming about wealth and love.


Jack gets onto the ship only because he won a card game. Free spirit, open to possibility, discovers his great love and all that jazz so beloved of the spontaneity as a philosophy crowd. Except he loses his life after freezing his ass off, so maybe he would have been better off losing.  Rose is unhappy because she is an upper class girl being pushed into a marriage that will save her and her mother from the financial pickle her father left them in. This behaviour is so abnormal in the class context that only our romantic illusions can give it any credibility. Jane Austen knew better, which is why the sheer hard-nosed calculations of Pride and Prejudice will always resonate at a deeper level than this imaginary authenticity of love.  But the manner in which the two characters are framed, we are being driven deep into a conditioning that has served the haves of society well, the pathetic belief that the poor are joyous and the rich burdened with lack of freedom. The implication is clear, if you choose money then you cannot be happy. And rich people are shown to be so dreary and boring, with tedious discourse and stiff manners, which the steerage passengers of course dance and whoop and smile. So actual real fun is possible only in unhygienic crowds, who are also more accepting of a person from another social class than all the evil rich people. In reality ,and also in the time period shown, Rose would have been met with a wall of hostility from third class. But that will not ennoble poverty  and deepen romantic sentiment so it is kept out.



Rich people behave despicably when the iceberg pops up. The rich fiancé even tries to hijack a baby to get into a boat   and Rose’s mother makes disdainful remarks about not wishing to be with the hoi polloi. All of this feeds into the template of rich people being jerks by default. Cameron became a very rich man by understanding how ordinary people think and feel. Rose has been rebelling against her corsets and stifling upbringing by cheating on the man to whom she is after all engaged. They make the beast with two backs in some poor guy’s car. Love apparently is excuse enough to soil another person’s property with your bodily fluids. She allows Jack to save her and sacrifice himself  - why is her life worth more? Why does she accept this as her due? But it is with regard to the famous necklace that Rose proves she has a breath-taking sense of entitlement. She hates the guy who gave it to her, but because she wore it while being sketched in the nude and bumping ugly, she hangs onto it for years till she is about to expire - when she throws it back into the ocean instead of selling it and setting up her granddaughter who has been taking care of her.  Despising the man who gave it you is no reason to spurn the jewellery itself; many women have made this refreshing discovery. At one point she snarls at her fiancé that, “I would rather be his whore than your wife.” which is an extraordinary line in a supposedly romantic movie. Well self-recognition is always good.  
Rose is just about the most unpleasant female character Cameron has ever put on screen and that includes the Alien Queen. Jack was lucky. 

 
Rohit Arya is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a cultural critic and social commentator for two decades. Rohit is the author of 5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi, Polymath. Rohit is also a Lineage Master in the Eight Spiritual Breaths system of Yoga

1 comment:

  1. I never watched this movie. I don't understand how humans can have disasters happen and then make movies about those disasters as if it was something to be celebrated. None of this invented stuff happened and nobody sang a song, people were probably very scared on the real boat and things didn't end up well. Battle movies I can understand since it is history and people learn better with some drama but plane crash or similar catastrophe stuff irritates me. Hmmm... well maybe I should not really open my mouth about movies in general because I tend not to watch any fiction whatsoever... it generates ín me too many feelings that someone else wanted me to feel and I have enough with mine already, thank you. I suppose I should just should accept that the vast majority of people like to watch someone else live a great (or not so great) fictional life on a screen.

    ReplyDelete