I have had a
learning moment with some workers hired by the building society to repair the
outer walls of our flats. Here is the insight - Being nice does not get you
much leverage in India. It is not a very pleasant thing to acknowledge but it
is very significant.
A couple of
weeks back a group of workers had erected a scaffolding outside my 7th
floor window. Since it is so high I have no grill, and this was a concern for
me. I got into conversation with them to find out how long this nuisance would
continue and also, I admit because I was a little wary and wanted their names
in case something suddenly went missing! So far, so good. Many of them were
Bangladeshis, almost certainly illegally here but that is another story – their
poverty drives them almost 3500 kms to risk life and limb a hundred feet up… I
can accommodate that. But when they discovered I knew Bengali, a holdover from
my Kolkata childhood as well as that I recognized many of them as being
Bangladeshi – they denied it with grins – something unfortunate happened. They
are not used to being spoken nicely to and they decided I was therefore their
friend!
A request
for water to drink was the first misstep. In the heat of India to refuse water
is a deeply rooted act of shame so I got some for them. They saw I had a fridge
and requested cold water. I made a second blunder and gave them a bottle. From
then on I had at least seven or eight interruptions a day; I work mostly at
home as a writer and of course that is not ‘real work’; people have no qualms
about interrupting that or expecting you to set it aside for their concerns. It
is only writing, can you not resume it later? This foolishness permeates every
single strata of society, the educated perhaps being worse violators of your
time than day workers. By the end of the first day the news had spread that
there was a soft touch existing in the complex and bottles were being asked for
workers on other buildings. By the third day my patience was already wearing
thin when in the afternoon one of them wanted to use my loo. I went ballistic
and initiated a rapid display of my comprehensive knowledge of vernacular
abuses. Naturally that impressed the hell out of them and I was left in peace.
Such is life. This week another work crew replaced the original lot and one
remnant with them gambled that I had calmed down by now. The request for water
opened the proceedings. I turned them down flat, not making the mistake of
explaining my reasons. I just said no and shut the door. They smile at me when
I go out of the building. This is the nature of our society. The harsh and
unapologetic are held in esteem; the nice are exploited.
Sociologists
have defined this as the boundary problem. People who are destitute in
non-industrialized societies, societies which do not have modernity as an
operating paradigm, have nothing. When they are suddenly given something they
do not have the metal categories to correctly comprehend or categorise it. To have
nothing, suddenly be given access to something, is to create an expectation for
everything. To do a favour, creates, in short, entitlement. In India it is even
stronger as it activates the ancient Yajmaan
dynamic, the patron-dependant dyad. To show interest in, or to assist in
any manner is an assumption or responsibility, they can depend upon you now. To
assist without any intention of continuing beyond that preliminary assistance
is unconsciously felt to be cruel and unfeeling; it is better to have left them
in their initial misery. The fault therefore was entirely mine. I have had this
trouble before and I still didn’t learn till this moment. When in Pune city I
used to go to an internet café and chatted occasionally with the young man who
used to take the payments and clean the place.
One day I gave him a pair of impulse purchase shoes which I had not worn
more than twice. It completely demoralized him. Next day he asked if he could
become my room-mate as I lived very close to the Internet café and he had to
commute a lot. Such gifts were not in
the realm of his possibilities. Now that it had happened there was only one
explanation – I was his friend. A hundred sentimental films and books had told
him that therefore everything that was mine was also his. My refusals were met
with continual incomprehension, until I realized I have to be rude and
insulting for the point to register, for that is familiar and acceptable. I
made a similar blunder with an office boy once. A few weeks after the gift a
request was made for another pair, as he had apparently damaged them crossing
the railways tracks. What actually happened of course was that he had made a
gift of them at some wedding thus gaining considerable social cachet. When I
told him my deduction that his jaw dropped in consternation at being found out,
but, and this is the point, it did not in any way decrease his hopes that I
would fulfil my side of the unconscious contract. I had aroused hopes. I was
responsible now.
The other
way this functions is something peculiar I have noticed – for a considerable
number of Indians the word ‘Gift’ means, “Please keep this with you until I
suddenly discover a need for it when I will of course require its return.” It
perhaps explains why one of the ancient rules for those entering Yoga is to not
accept gifts. I violate all sorts of social norms by loudly requiring multiple
assurances that it is a gift and not something that is to be stored rent free
at my house. The embarrassment and resentment this causes is considerable but
nothing compared to the anger I used to feel when the thing was yanked away. Nowadays
I refuse to take gifts point blank. At some deep unconscious level in the
Indian mind there is a conviction if you have not paid for something, it does
not belong to you. This normally goes hand in hand with another behaviour, the
“You are just like family” pattern. It is completely dishonest and they are
utterly sincere when they mean it. Blood however is thicker than water and you
are always water, no alchemy will ever alter that. I bluntly tell people, “You
get to say that fatuity once with me. Say it again and I will break the
friendship” and then I follow through purely on principle for I know the day
will inevitably come when it will have to be done in bitterness. The
articulation of the sentiment is for talismanic purposes; I am too old for such
unaware interactions and too tired to educate or overlook. I have learned to
care for myself however and that is good.
Rohit Arya
is the Editor of The Leadership Review, and a corporate trainer. He has been a
cultural critic and social commentator for two decades. Rohit is the author of
5 books and been published in 5 European languages. He is an Author, Yogi,
Polymath. Rohit is also a Lineage Master in the
Eight Spiritual Breaths system of Yoga










